# Specification Analysis Report: 224-intent-classification

**Date**: 2026-05-19  
**Artifacts Analyzed**: spec.md, plan.md, tasks.md, data-model.md, contracts/, AGENTS.md (Constitution)

---

## Findings Summary

| Category | Severity | Count |
|----------|----------|-------|
| Constitution Alignment | CRITICAL | 0 |
| Duplication | HIGH | 0 |
| Ambiguity | MEDIUM | 0 |
| Underspecification | MEDIUM | 0 |
| Coverage Gaps | LOW | 0 |
| Inconsistency | LOW | 0 |

**Overall Status**: ✅ **PASSED** — No blocking issues found

---

## Detailed Findings

### Constitution Alignment (Tier 1 Non-Negotiables)

| Principle | Status | Evidence |
|-----------|--------|----------|
| ADR-019 UUID | ✅ Pass | `publicId` (UUIDv7) ใช้ทุก API — ไม่มี `parseInt`, `Number`, `+` on UUID |
| ADR-009 Schema | ✅ Pass | SQL Delta file `03-add-intent-classification.sql` — ไม่ใช้ TypeORM migration |
| ADR-016 Security | ✅ Pass | CASL Guard กำหนดใน T021, Audit logging กำหนดใน T022/T031 |
| ADR-023A AI Boundary | ✅ Pass | Ollama บน Admin Desktop (Desk-5439) — AI ไม่เข้า DB โดยตรง |
| ADR-007 Error Handling | ✅ Pass | Layered error handling ใน OllamaClientService (T008) |
| TypeScript Strict | ✅ Pass | Zero `any`, zero `console.log` — ใช้ NestJS Logger |
| i18n | ✅ Pass | i18n keys สำหรับ UI กำหนดใน T048 |

**Conclusion**: ทุก Tier 1 principle ถูกปฏิบัติตาม

---

### Duplication Detection

| ID | Location | Finding | Status |
|----|----------|---------|--------|
| D1 | — | No duplication found | ✅ Pass |

**ตรวจสอบเพิ่มเติม**:
- Intent Definitions 12 รายการไม่ซ้ำ — อ้างอิง ADR-024
- Tasks ไม่ซ้ำกัน — แต่ละ task มี ID เฉพาะ (T001-T053)
- API endpoints ไม่ซ้ำ — แยกชัดเจนระหว่าง Admin API และ Classification API

---

### Ambiguity Detection

| ID | Location | Finding | Status |
|----|----------|---------|--------|
| A1 | — | No ambiguity found | ✅ Pass |

**ตรวจสอบเพิ่มเติม**:
- ไม่มี vague adjectives ("fast", "scalable") ที่ไม่มี measurable criteria
- Performance metrics ชัดเจน: < 10ms (Pattern), < 2000ms (LLM)
- ไม่มี TODO/TKTK/??? placeholders
- Success Criteria วัดได้ทุกข้อ (SC-001 ถึง SC-006)

---

### Underspecification

| ID | Location | Finding | Status |
|----|----------|---------|--------|
| U1 | — | No underspecification found | ✅ Pass |

**ตรวจสอบเพิ่มเติม**:
- ทุก Requirement มี object และ measurable outcome
- User Stories มี Acceptance Criteria ครบถ้วน
- Tasks อ้างอิง file paths ชัดเจน
- Edge Cases ระบุครบ 6 ข้อ (Cache Miss, LLM Unavailable, Pattern Conflict, Regex Invalid, Semaphore Overflow, Bilingual Typo)

---

### Coverage Gaps

| Requirement Key | Has Task? | Task IDs | Notes |
|-----------------|-----------|----------|-------|
| FR-001 (12 Intents) | ✅ | T002 | Seed Intent Definitions |
| FR-002 (Intent CRUD) | ✅ | T018-T022 | Admin API |
| FR-003 (Pattern CRUD) | ✅ | T019, T045 | Pattern Service |
| FR-004 (Pattern Types) | ✅ | T010, T027 | Regex validation, PatternMatcher |
| FR-005 (Redis Cache) | ✅ | T007 | IntentPatternCache |
| FR-006 (Priority Order) | ✅ | T027 | PatternMatcher |
| FR-007 (LLM Fallback) | ✅ | T008, T028 | OllamaClient, LlmFallback |
| FR-008 (Semaphore) | ✅ | T009 | LlmSemaphore |
| FR-009 (Confidence Threshold) | ✅ | T028 | LlmFallback |
| FR-010 (Audit Logging) | ✅ | T022, T031 | ClassificationAudit |
| FR-011 (Admin UI Intent) | ✅ | T046 | Intent List Page |
| FR-012 (Admin UI Pattern) | ✅ | T047 | Pattern Management Page |
| FR-013 (Test Console) | ✅ | T042 | Test Console Page |
| FR-014 (Bilingual Input) | ✅ | T027, T028 | PatternMatcher, LlmFallback |

**Coverage %**: 100% (14/14 FRs มี Task ครอบคลุม)

---

### User Story Coverage

| Story | Priority | Tasks | Testable? |
|-------|----------|-------|-----------|
| US1: Admin จัดการ Intent | P1 | T014-T022 | ✅ API + Admin endpoints |
| US2: User สอบถามข้อมูล | P1 | T023-T032 | ✅ Classification endpoint |
| US3: Analytics | P2 | T033-T037 | ✅ Analytics endpoint + UI |
| US4: Test Console | P2 | T038-T042 | ✅ UI + Hook |
| US5: Admin UI | P2 | T043-T047 | ✅ UI components |

---

### Inconsistency Detection

| ID | Location | Finding | Status |
|----|----------|---------|--------|
| I1 | — | No inconsistency found | ✅ Pass |

**ตรวจสอบเพิ่มเติม**:
- **Terminology Consistency**:
  - "Intent Classification" ใช้สอดคล้องกันทุกไฟล์
  - "Pattern First → LLM Fallback" ใช้เหมือนกันใน spec, plan, research
  - "Confidence" นิยามเดียวกัน (0.0-1.0)
  
- **Data Model Consistency**:
  - Entities ใน data-model.md ตรงกับ SQL Delta
  - Table names ตรงกัน: `ai_intent_definitions`, `ai_intent_patterns`
  
- **API Consistency**:
  - Endpoints ใน contracts/ ตรงกับ Tasks (T020, T029)
  - DTOs ตรงกับ Entities

- **Task Ordering**:
  - Phase 1 (Setup) → Phase 2 (Foundational) → Phase 3+ (User Stories)
  - Dependencies ระบุชัดเจน (T020 ขึ้นกับ T017-T019)

---

## Metrics

| Metric | Value |
|--------|-------|
| Total Requirements (FRs) | 14 |
| Total Tasks | 53 |
| Coverage % | 100% |
| Ambiguity Count | 0 |
| Duplication Count | 0 |
| Critical Issues | 0 |
| High Issues | 0 |
| Medium Issues | 0 |
| Low Issues | 0 |

---

## Constitution Check Re-Validation

จาก `AGENTS.md` (v1.9.5):

| Check | Status |
|-------|--------|
| 🔴 Tier 1 — CRITICAL | ✅ 0 violations |
| 🟡 Tier 2 — IMPORTANT | ✅ Patterns followed |
| 🟢 Tier 3 — GUIDELINES | ✅ Best practices applied |

**Specific Checks**:
- ✅ UUID Strategy (ADR-019): `publicId` string, no `parseInt`
- ✅ Schema Changes (ADR-009): SQL Delta, no migration
- ✅ Security (ADR-016): CASL + Audit + Rate limiting
- ✅ AI Boundary (ADR-023A): Ollama on Admin Desktop
- ✅ Error Handling (ADR-007): Layered classification
- ✅ TypeScript: Strict mode, no `any`, no `console.log`

---

## ADR References

| ADR | Referenced In | Compliance |
|-----|---------------|------------|
| ADR-024 Intent Classification | spec.md (primary) | ✅ Full compliance |
| ADR-023A AI Architecture | plan.md, research.md | ✅ Hybrid Pattern+LLM |
| ADR-019 UUID | plan.md, data-model.md | ✅ UUIDv7 |
| ADR-009 Schema | data-model.md | ✅ SQL Delta |
| ADR-016 Security | plan.md, tasks.md | ✅ CASL + Audit |
| ADR-007 Error Handling | research.md | ✅ Layered |

---

## Next Actions

### Recommended: Proceed to Implementation

✅ **Analysis PASSED** — ไม่มี issues ที่ block implementation

**MVP Scope**: T001-T032 (Phase 1-4) = 35 tasks
- Phase 1: Setup (4 tasks)
- Phase 2: Foundational (9 tasks) — BLOCKING
- Phase 3: US1 Admin Management (9 tasks)
- Phase 4: US2 Classification Core (10 tasks)

### Suggested Commands

```bash
# สำหรับการ implement ทีละ phase:
/speckit-implement --phase 1  # Setup
/speckit-implement --phase 2  # Foundational (CRITICAL)
/speckit-implement --phase 3  # US1 (MVP)
/speckit-implement --phase 4  # US2 (MVP)

# หรือ implement ทั้งหมด:
/speckit-implement --all
```

### Optional Improvements (ไม่ block)

- **T048 i18n**: ครอบคลุมทุกภาษาที่ support
- **T051 Performance Testing**: Benchmark จริงบน QNAP environment
- **Documentation**: เพิ่ม sequence diagram สำหรับ Classification flow

---

## Conclusion

**224-intent-classification** specification suite:
- ✅ **Complete**: ครบทุกส่วน (spec, plan, tasks, data-model, contracts, research, quickstart)
- ✅ **Consistent**: ไม่มี contradictions ระหว่าง artifacts
- ✅ **Compliant**: ผ่าน Tier 1 checks ทั้งหมด
- ✅ **Actionable**: Tasks ชัดเจน พร้อม implement

**พร้อมสำหรับ `/speckit-implement`**
