# Specification Analysis Report

**Feature**: AI Console UX Refactor
**Date**: 2026-06-18
**Artifacts Analyzed**: spec.md, plan.md, tasks.md

## Findings Summary

| ID  | Category    | Severity | Location(s)      | Summary                      | Recommendation                       |
| --- | ----------- | -------- | ---------------- | ---------------------------- | ------------------------------------ |
| A1  | Coverage    | LOW      | tasks.md         | FR-007 (responsive layout) has no dedicated implementation task | Add responsive layout verification task to Polish phase |
| A2  | Inconsistency | LOW     | plan.md:line 221 | Plan mentions removing empty TabsContent but tasks.md doesn't explicitly include this as a separate task | Task T005 covers this - no action needed |

## Coverage Summary Table

| Requirement Key | Has Task? | Task IDs | Notes |
| --------------- | --------- | -------- | ----- |
| display-accurate-page-description | YES | T001 | Direct mapping to FR-001 |
| display-health-cards-above-tabs | YES | T002-T006 | Covers FR-002, FR-005, FR-006 |
| rename-overview-tab | YES | T007 | Covers FR-003 |
| rename-ocr-sandbox-tab | YES | T008-T009 | Covers FR-004 |
| maintain-health-polling | YES | T006 | Covers FR-005 |
| preserve-tab-navigation | YES | T010 | Covers FR-006 |
| ensure-responsive-layout | PARTIAL | T017 | FR-007 covered only in Polish phase testing, not implementation |

## Constitution Alignment Issues

**None detected.** All requirements align with project constitution:
- Frontend-only refactor (no backend changes) - ✅
- TypeScript strict mode compliance - ✅
- No new database changes - ✅
- No security violations - ✅
- No UUID handling issues - ✅

## Unmapped Tasks

**None detected.** All tasks map to user stories or polish phase.

## Metrics

- **Total Requirements**: 7 (FR-001 through FR-007)
- **Total Tasks**: 17 (T001 through T017)
- **Coverage %**: 100% (all requirements have at least one task)
- **Ambiguity Count**: 0 (all requirements are clear and measurable)
- **Duplication Count**: 0 (no duplicate requirements)
- **Critical Issues Count**: 0

## Detailed Analysis

### Duplication Detection
- **Status**: PASS
- **Findings**: No duplicate requirements detected. Each functional requirement addresses a distinct aspect of the UX refactor.

### Ambiguity Detection
- **Status**: PASS
- **Findings**: No vague adjectives or placeholders detected. All requirements use specific, measurable language (e.g., "30-second interval", "above the tab navigation", "System Toggle").

### Underspecification
- **Status**: PASS
- **Findings**: All requirements have clear objects and measurable outcomes. Edge cases are well-documented in spec.md.

### Constitution Alignment
- **Status**: PASS
- **Findings**: No conflicts with project constitution. Feature is a pure UI refactor with no backend, database, or security implications.

### Coverage Gaps
- **Status**: MINOR
- **Findings**: FR-007 (responsive layout) is covered only in the Polish phase testing task (T017), not as an explicit implementation task. This is acceptable since the existing grid layout is assumed to work correctly when moved above tabs (documented in spec.md assumptions).

### Inconsistency
- **Status**: MINOR
- **Findings**: Plan.md line 221 mentions removing empty TabsContent, which is covered by task T005 but not explicitly called out as a separate task. This is a minor documentation difference, not a functional gap.

## Next Actions

**Status**: READY FOR IMPLEMENTATION

- No CRITICAL or HIGH severity issues detected
- All LOW/MEDIUM issues are documentation-related and do not block implementation
- User may proceed with `/speckit-implement` or manual implementation
- Optional improvement: Consider adding a dedicated responsive layout verification task if FR-007 is deemed critical

**Recommended Command**: Proceed with implementation using tasks.md as the execution guide.

---

## Remediation Offer

Would you like me to suggest concrete remediation edits for the minor issues identified (A1, A2)?
